
Brainstorming continues to be a common method to try and shake out the cobwebs and draw out new ideas from teams. In practice however, the outcome of brainstorming often falls short of expectations as team get stymied by a stalled creative front. Psychological inertia, hidden agenda, lack of insight can all contribute to these non-productive innovation weather patterns. To understand how people can influence the brainstorming outcome, let’s look to the wisdom of the cloud.
There are a number of different types of clouds, each with its own make up and effect on the weather. So too are there difference classes of participants in a brainstorming exercise. Can you recognize the similarities?
Cumulus clouds are puffy and cheerful. These clouds are willing participants in the brainstorming exercise, but rarely contribute any significant ideas. They tend to revel in the exercise and cheer on other cumulus clouds by seeing the shapes of imagined novelty in what are in reality the same old concepts.
Cirrus clouds are high and wispy. They often bring some very high-level ideas to the table. But, the ideas are generally not deep and may lack good alignment with the overall business objectives. It can be a challenge to distinguish between the cirrus idea that could have value if it were only further developed and the concept which is going to simply drain valuable resources to explore and kill because it is not a good fit.
Fog. Need we say more. We can all recognize the team member who just doesn’t seem to have a clue.
Cumulonimbus clouds have presence. They are large and have great substance. But they can also bring great destruction as they unleash their energy. These people often harbor hidden agenda. The tornado of energy is released not so much to advance the cause, but to tear down the ideas of other in an attempt to perpetuate their own views and goals.
Nimbostratus are the clouds that yield steady rain. It is sometimes uncomfortable to want in the rain, but as any farmer will tell you, you need water to grow crops. The reason these peoples’ ideas often feel uncomfortable is that these concepts are grounded—they are novel enough to simulate that instinct to resist change, but grounded in enough reality to seem achievable. These are often the most productive member of the brainstorming team.
If we want to stimulate more innovation rain, how can we do this? Seed the clouds with knowledge.
Brainstorming doesn’t create new ideas. It simply helps people tap into what they have forgotten they know. The more relevant knowledge they have access to, the more ease with which they can access that knowledge in a useful way, the more likely they are to make the connections that produce that moment of creative synthesis.
Connecting innovation workers to the right knowledge at the right time is a key aspect of how you can increase the innovation productivity of your organization in brainstorming and other innovation activities as well.









In Defense of Improvement
A colleague pointed out a post by Patrick Lefler that appeared on Chuck Frey’s Innovation Tools site this week. In this article, Patrick proclaims that improvement is not innovation. Of course, in the purest sense, the author is correct. While all innovation seeks to deliver an improvement, not all improvements are innovative. But, there is a very important aspect of improvement that, in his fervor to make his point, Patrick has ignored.
Coincidentally, I presented a webinar just yesterday on the topic of harnessing innovation creativity to drive corporate value. One of the key points I touched on was the importance of incremental innovation. Yes, incremental innovation is a good and necessary part of building a sustainable culture and environment for continuous innovation.
Breakthrough innovation, incremental innovation, minor improvement—these are all points on a continuum of value creating solution generation. Incremental innovation is very beneficial to an organization trying to develop the core competence needed to support a high-performance innovation system. Specifically, incremental innovation delivers both short and long term benefits. In the short term, immediate business benefits can be realized—extended revenue life of a product, increased market share, better contribution to margin, etc. In the long term, incremental innovation provides a low risk platform to hone the basic innovation skills needed for successful, repeatable breakthrough innovation practice.
This last point, honing basic innovation skills, is too often overlooked. Most organizations lack these basic skills and the knowledge of innovation best practices. These skills must be developed and practiced constantly. Even seasoned innovation workers should take a page from Basketball legend Larry Bird’s play book. Larry was well known for his work ethic and diligence in maintaining his skills. He would arrive for a game hours before anyone else and warm up by taking hundreds of practice shots.
Efforts to improve, even modest ones, are opportunities to practice innovation thinking and skills. The adept application of innovation practices can move a change further along the continuum of novelty and value creation so that what might have been a minor improvement becomes an incremental innovation that creates strong competitive differentiation.
So while Patrick is correct in the assertion that simple improvements are not innovations, one should not eschew incremental achievements. In fact sometimes the road to breakthrough innovations is paved a brick at a time. In my own research team where we are constantly pushing the limits and redefining the concept of the possible in the area of applied computational linguistics, we often use the expression “step by step” to describe the path to innovation success.
Of course, it’s important to remember that you must be constantly trying to reach further up the novelty-value ladder in order to find the breakthroughs that will provide you optimal market position. But don’t forget to embrace incremental innovation, too. It’s a good thing.
Posted at 10:30 AM in Commentary, High Performance Innovation, Innovation Techniques, Weblogs | Permalink | Comments (6) | TrackBack (0)
Reblog (0) | | Digg This | Save to del.icio.us |